Berkey PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Reduction Elements, 2-Pack

  • Specialty Resin
  • Gravity-fed
  • Filter life 6-12 months
  • 6-month warranty
Notscored
4.4
SocialScore
Versus

Add-on fluoride and arsenic elements for Berkey systems, rated for 1,000 gallons or a year per pair.

$103

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never affects our scores. How this works

SKU: PF-2 Category: Brand:

The review

The only Berkey route to fluoride reduction, but tests found aluminium

The Berkey PF-2 is a pair of activated alumina add-on elements that hang below the primary elements to reduce fluoride and arsenic.

Certification coverage

No certifier lists the PF-2, and as a replacement part, so it is not scored on Certification Coverage.

Flow rate

Its flow depends on the system it sits in, so it is not scored on Flow Rate.

Filter life
  • As a replacement part judged inside its system, its reductions are read on the systems, so it is not scored on Contaminant Reduction.
  • Its capacity is a gallon rating rather than a service interval for a whole system, so it is not scored on Filter Life.
Build quality

It has no housing of its own to judge, so it is not scored on Build Quality.

Ease of installation

It drops into an existing system, so it is not scored on Ease of Installation.

Value

With no other criterion scored, so it is not scored on Value.

Warranty & support

Its warranty is a parts term rather than a system promise, so it is not scored on Warranty & Support.

Price

$103.00 at bigberkeywaterfilters.com.

Verdict

It suits a Berkey owner on fluoridated water who wants it reduced, and who accepts frequent replacement.

This is a replacement cartridge for a specific housing, so it is not scored against the eight criteria.

Social score

4.4 out of 10
RedditBrand-level3 out of 10

r/WaterTreatment owners mostly ask how to replace a Berkey now that Black Berkey elements are not sold on their own (Aug 2026, Apr 2026)|In a Big Berkey alternatives thread one owner warns the PF-2 media is aluminium based and another bought unbranded elements on Amazon (Jun 2025); owners note Berkey leaves calcium and magnesium in the water (May 2024)

Google4 out of 10
Liked
  • fluoride removed in the retest
Complaints
  • aluminium added to the water
  • results vary between sets
Read the full summary

Water Filter Guru (Brian Campbell) found PF-2 elements added 1.44 ppm aluminium to its city water in a first Tap Score test; a second set removed fluoride, with aluminium up 32% but under the guideline (updated Apr 2026)|BOS Water (Sara and Raoul) measured 67% fluoride reduction on Black Berkey plus PF-2 elements and flags possible aluminium leaching (updated Nov 2026; affiliate links)

YouTubeBrand-level2 out of 10

Water Filter Guru, which tested Berkey systems twice, published a video on what happened to Berkey and the certified gravity filters it now uses instead (Jun 2026, about 230,000 views)

Amazon8 out of 10

Amazon US lists the PF-2 two-pack (B00BWIWYBW) at 4.5 out of 5 from 2,491 ratings, 81% five-star and 7% one-star (Dec 2025)

User reviewsBrand-level5 out of 10

Walmart's Berkey files read 4.6 out of 5 from 37 reviews on the blemished systems and 3.5 to 3.8 on Black Berkey element sets; no PF-2 listing there has ten reviews (Oct 2026)

Not countedExcluded

First-party reviews on the dealer's own store and on Berkey's own channels count in no pool.

Company
  • Berkey is made by New Millennium Concepts, Ltd., a company based in Arlington, Texas, that owns the brand and makes the systems and their parts.
  • Black Berkey elements are made by Berkey International, LLC, a Puerto Rico company that works with New Millennium Concepts.
Where it sells
  • New Millennium Concepts sells through authorized dealers such as bigberkeywaterfilters.com, and Berkey products are also sold on Amazon and by marketplace sellers on Walmart.
  • The retailer pool rests on marketplace sellers' listings, where few Berkey listings reach ten reviews.
Reviews

The Trustpilot profile for berkeywater.com is unclaimed and holds no reviews (November 2026).

Track record
  • The BBB rates New Millennium Concepts A+ and has accredited it since 2005, with 1 complaint in the last three years (November 2026).
  • EPA stop sale orders of 2022 and 2023 cover Black Berkey filter products, and on September 18, 2026 a federal appeals court left the 2023 order in place.
  • CPSC and Health Canada list no recall of Berkey water filters (November 2026).
Warranty and returns
  • Black Berkey elements carry a 2-year prorated warranty, Phoenix elements 1 year and PF-2 elements 6 months.
  • Stainless chambers and hardware bought on bigberkeywaterfilters.com carry its lifetime warranty, and unused items may be returned within 30 days.

Specs

  • Filtration TypeSpecialty Resin
  • CertificationsNot certified
  • Warranty6 Months
  • Connection SizeNo plumbing connection
  • Housing MaterialPolypropylene
  • Flow Rate / Water PressureGravity-fed
  • Filter Lifespan / Capacity6-12 months
  • Weight2 lb (shipping)
  • Country of OriginUSA
  • Contaminant RemovalAluminumArsenicCadmiumChromiumCopperFluorideLeadMercury

At a glance

  • Activated alumina media
  • One per primary element
  • Polypropylene #5 shell

The Berkey PF-2 is a pair of add-on elements that thread onto the stems of Black Berkey or Phoenix elements in the lower chamber to reduce fluoride and arsenic. The media is activated alumina in a BPA-free polypropylene #5 shell, made and assembled in the USA by NMCL.

The dealer rates a pair for 1,000 gallons or one year, whichever comes first, and up to 99.75% fluoride reduction under optimum conditions. They work best between pH 5 and 7, slow the system by about 15 to 20%, do not fit the Go Berkey and carry a 6-month warranty.

Questions answered from our data

All questions we answer

Stuff VS Things
Logo
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Versus
0
Shopping cart